You'd Be Surprised Rothstein vents to Nucky and delivers a message to Gyp. Gaston Means sees an opportunity. Billie gets a new co-start. Van Alden and Sigrid receive an unexpected visitor. Gillian worries about her business. Details Casts Title You'd Be Surprised Genres Crime Drama Release Date 2012-10-14 Episode Runtime 01 Hours 00 Minutes Season Number 3 Episode Number 5 Production Companies Closest to the Hole Productions, Sikelia Productions, Leverage Entertainment, Cold Front Productions Steve Buscemi Enoch "Nucky" Thompson Kelly Macdonald Margaret Schroeder / Mar? Michael Shannon Nelson Van Alden Shea Whigham Elias "Eli" Thompson Michael Stuhlbarg Arnold Rothstein Stephen Graham Al Capone Vincent Piazza Charles "Lucky" Luciano Michael Kenneth Williams Albert "Chalky" White Anthony Laciura Edward "Eddie" Kessler Paul Sparks Mieczysław "Mickey" Doyle Jack Huston Richard Harrow Gretchen Mol Gillian Darmody Charlie Cox Owen Sleater Bobby Cannavale Giuseppe "Gyp" Rosetti